Name: Mally Evercolor Starlight Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner
Brand: Mally
SKU: be0fc9b4-02d9-4f4e-bc76-e592ac533f1f
Rating: 4.6 (30 reviews)

Mally

Ready to take your eyes to the next level? The award-winning Starlight Eyeliner is Mally’s best kept secret for high-performance and stunning eye looks. These professional gel pencils glide on easily and provide an instant impact of color. It’s transfer-proof, crease-proof, smudge-proof, waterproof and one could say bulletproof so your eyes will look bold all day long!

Mally is an celebrity makeup artist that created her own cosmetic line, so I would say she knows her stuff. I am picky when it comes to “waterproof” products because usually they aren’t waterproof or aren’t good for your lashes. Mally Evercolor Starlight Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner is a gel pencil that is creamy and goes on very smoothly. The color espresso is a dark chocolate brown. It is smudge-proof and transfer proof once you let it set, people please let this dry down. I am able to say this because I have a slightly hooded eye and certain eyeliners do transfer. Eyeliners also have a tendency of slightly running underneath my eyes and let me tell you that once this sets it doesn’t move. The evercolor starlight liner is also waterproof. I have used this for tightlining and since it’s so creamy there’s no problem. Another trick you can do is before it sets, you do have some playtime if u want to created that smokey look or blend it out so the line isn’t as harsh. Mally please come out with some fun colors, a cobalt blue or a pretty turquoise !

Makeup Experts

Beauty Retail Expert

Other Specialized Beauty Professional

I've fallen in love with so many of Mally's products. She just seems to know her audience and delivers an affordable brand that looks amazing and performs just as well. I have Asian eyes that are hooded so finding an eyeliner that I love has been a journey. Waterproof felt tip has been my jam BUT I've always loved the ease of a creamy pencil. However most pencils smudge and leave me looking like a racooon. I'm also 38 so I cant and won't even bother with pencils that drag the fine skin of the eye. Mally's formula glides like butter but doesn't smudge! I also have a pool so we have lots of swim days. This has left my liner perfect. As a five year veteran in the high end skincare retail industry, pencils become holy grails and I think I just found one.

My name is Michelle, I'm very new to Beautytap. I have been selling natural skincare and professional make up with LimeLife for almost two years. I was extremely excited to join Beautytap for the opportunity to try other kinds of products other then what I use on a normal basis! I am not a big eye liner lover, but I was excited to try Mally's Starlight waterproof eyeliner for something new. I really loved how creamy the texture is, it literally glided on like spreadable butter which I was not expecting. I have really wet eyes, they are always tearing so I love a product that is waterproof and smudge proof which I can say this eyeliner was! I really enjoyed the texture of the eye liner, thats what I loved best, the coloring was a rich dark chocolate coloring, I prefer black but this shade was very pretty.

Product Expert Reviews